I am back in the wonderful country of Guatemala this week, preparing for the National Association for the Practice of Anthropology - Occupational Therapy Field School. I was lucky enough to return to Antigua as the coordinator for this fantastic fieldwork experience for both anthropology and occupational therapy students. We will be going on a whirlwind adventure of four weeks exploring and researching various topics including Pediatric Development, Sustainable Technology, and NGO Networks in Health.
Before that adventure begins, I have had some time this week, as we prepare for the fast paced weeks to come, to explore and spend some time simply being in Antigua. Today, I found myself sitting on a bench in the middle of the city. In the center of this small colonial town sits Parque Central, a hive of activity, events, and interactions. People, both Guatemalan and foreign, walk, talk, and move throughout the green plants, cobblestone streets, and small stores. Venders selling ice cream, bracelets, table centerpieces, and shoe shines meander through the park gently and sometimes more aggressively engaging with those passing by or seated on the benches. Tour guides and instant photographers linger around the fountain in the middle of the square, waiting for someone who needs their services. Young children play around the fountain and old men smoke cigars, commenting on scantily clad gringas walking by. Pairs of police officers wearing intimidating military-like uniforms stroll through the area eyeing the people with a heightened awareness.
Guatemalan teenage school girls sit in a circle around one of the benches in the park surrounding a laptop computer looking at something that periodically makes them shriek like... well... school girls. They giggle and glance at the older boys who walk passed them, all of them dressed in the typical white and blue uniforms of Guatemalan public schools. A young mother and her child sit near the edge of the fountain. The little boy chases the pigeons as she texts on her cell phone, taking a moment to stop and give her child a peck on the lips when he approaches. Today, there is an event for a local gym in which children from all the local schools came out and did something akin to Zumba with the gym's instructors. There was music and microphones echoing throughout the square, but one could always still hear the constant flow and splash of the center fountain over it all.
As I sat on that bench I pulled out my old Spanish class notes to review some vocabulary. After a few pages, I realized there was no way I would remember any of it with everything happening around me so I opened my notebook and began journaling some thoughts. As I looked around, the majority of other park-goers who were sitting on benches had no notebooks, books to read, crosswords to fill out, or even cameras to take pictures. They were doing nothing. I realized I had pulled out my notebooks to provide some impression that I was not just sitting there watching everyone; I was being productive and had a reason for sitting down and being in the park. However everyone else had no intention of creating an image of productivity, they were doing nothing. Doing nothing, what an interesting idea. Is it even possible?
I guess in reality, these people were doing. They were talking with each other, they were simply being present in the community, and they were watching, breathing, seeing, itching, smoking, hearing, touching, simply existing for a moment to experience the world around them. Such a foreign concept to my mind, marinaded in the protestant work ethic and the fast paced productive culture of the US. How often do you see people at the park in the US simply sitting and watching the other people at the park? They are reading a book, doing homework, exercising, or doing a variety of other things, but few are simply existing in the space, experiencing the world around them without being productive. We march through life with productivity as our goal.
As I sat staring into my world of occupation and analysis, I had stopped writing and was simply glancing around. In that moment, the Guatemalan man who was sitting near me on the bench began a conversation with me. We talked about his teacher in Guatemala City and about some sicknesses he had. He asked about why I was in Guatemala and how long. Then we stopped talking as he told me "I didn't mean to interrupt your work, you can continue working now." He went back to staring and I returned to my notebook.
My apparent productivity had stifled an opportunity to engage the people around me. Holding still in my productive timeline allowed someone else to catch up to me and connect. When I opened up to the world around me and allowed an empty space to emerge in my productive life, it was quickly filled with community. I wonder what else could fill up in those spaces if we just allowed them to happen? Maybe "doing nothing", something so countercultural, is actually an opportunity for the world to fill in the vacant corners of your life, allowing the nuances of people, the smells of the air, the sounds of a fountain, and the sights of a community to enter into the dance we call life. Maybe in spending some time "doing nothing" sometimes we learn to exist together and taste the diverse flavors of this world.
Wednesday, May 28, 2014
Wednesday, September 25, 2013
Crossing Borders, Culture Blindness, and Understanding the Client
As with most journeys like this one, I set out with a specific trajectory in mind, however I arrived at a very different destination than what I would have expected. My goal in
the beginning of this project was to understand how Occupational Therapy
was being provided to Guatemalans and Nicaraguans based in their own
culture and from native therapists in hopes of informing and developing
the approach therapists take when working with these specific
populations. My question was originally, "How does occupational therapy
change and adapt to the cultural differences of Guatemalans, indigenous
and ladino, and Nicaraguans?" When looking deeper into the current situation of these countries, along with the current status of Occupational Therapy in them, I realized this question was not so simply answered.
We believe that Occupational Therapy is a client-based profession, one in which therapists must understand their patients' goals and meaningful activities to truly provide effective therapy. However, naturally we, as therapists, employ our own cultural framework to expedite this process. We function from assumptions about our patients that are inherent to our own culture, using presumed and simply understood cultural paradigms to approach therapeutic intervention. When crossing cultures and even sub-cultures this becomes an obstacle to effective therapy delivery. To provide effective therapy to individuals from diverse socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds, therapists must step outside of what occupational therapy scholars have called "culture blindness", being immersed in one's own culture so comprehensively that the therapist does not recognize their own cultural influences in the therapeutic relationship.
From my experiences in Guatemala and Nicaragua, I have come to realize that for culture blindness to subside and culturally competent occupational therapy to be delivered, therapists must take a step back from their traditional and assumed interventions and approaches and begin to look first at the theoretical foundations of occupational therapy. Therapists must first shave off the culturally biased flavors in which occupational therapy has developed and discover the raw underlying philosophy of the profession. From there we can allow this raw philosophical seed to grow in the natural culture of our patients, bearing the appropriate interventions and approaches rooted in the patients' own cultures and experiences.
This process requires a variety of factors to be in place. The first and foremost is rich soil into which the occupational perspective can be placed. Resources, time, and support are all necessary for the occupational perspective to be cultivated within a population in a way that connects theory to the patient in an authentic and effective manner. Unfortunately, just as Guatemalan campesinos have little land to cultivate their own crops, Guatemala and Nicaragua have little room to develop the occupational perspective. In Guatemala, the healthcare system is overburdened, disjointed, plagued with ethnic tension, overrun with NGOs, and has little room for prioritizing occupational therapy. In Nicaragua, what little occupational therapy is present is restricted by economic and political limitations, having neither the time nor the resources to effective emerge through the Nicaraguan culture.
Secondly, for the occupational perspective to take root and emerge through a new culture it must be interpreted effectively. Because of the huge presence of NGOs, service organizations, and foreign aid in Guatemala, much of the therapy is provided by non-Guatemalans who, although with good intentions, may not be providing the most effective or appropriate interventions for Guatemalan people. On many occasions, therapists provide interventions and techniques that come directly from their experiences in their respective countries instead of providing the reasoning and underlying philosophy behind those interventions to native therapists or caregivers. This creates a situation where patients, family members, or caregivers are performing interventions that may not make sense, are not effective, and maybe even create more of a burden rather than alleviating a problem.
As caregivers or therapists begin to realize that these transplanted interventions are not effective with their population, for example in Nicaragua, they resort to simplified non-occupation based techniques that do not resemble true occupational therapy. The occupational perspective, which was cultivated in Western/Developed cultures, has not been effectively interpreted for cultural differences outside that paradigm. Occupational therapy, because it is such a client based approach, must be acculturated before it can be sustainably effective. For this to occur, occupational therapists must step outside their own cultural paradigms and begin to understand the many structural and contextual factors that influence the efficacy of the therapy.
Understanding that in Nicaragua, the idea of independence may not be the most meaningful concept for a 75 year old woman because culturally she expects her children to care for her. Understanding that the routine of an indigenous woman in Guatemala may not have the flexibility to provide extra exercises to her child with special needs. Understanding that the standard approaches and solutions for assistive equipment, adaptive solutions, or even safety procedures may not be accessible, affordable, available, or of high quality. Understanding that therapists are viewed with less authority and less respect in some cultures. Understanding that sickness, disability, poverty, and independence are all viewed very differently within these cultural contexts.
For therapists crossing borders, it is integral to first understand these factors that affect their clients' in order to be creative, innovative, and revolutionary practitioners and effectively facilitate rehabilitation and/or change. Therapists crossing borders, whether that be across national borders or stepping into a homeless camp, work with tools that both hinder and facilitate potential success in their practice, having to take the time and effort to understand the full context of their patients while also bringing a new and diverse perspective on ways to resolve obstacles for their clients. It is the responsibility of therapists to find a balance between these two, uncovering a manner in which they foster occupational justice while preventing the imposition of their own culture.
As a global community and a global profession, we must learn to share ideas across cultures effectively and dialogue between therapists, professions, and nations. As occupational therapists, the adaptive thinkers that we are, we approach obstacles from a new and exciting way, thinking of new and sustainable ways to overcome occupational injustice using innovative minds and passionate communities. When we hone the ability to apply the theory, values, and principles of our profession across cultures, socioeconomic statuses, gender, sexual orientation, religion, and countless other diverse contexts, we will make a new step in becoming a globalized profession seeking to support occupational justice for all people both locally and on an international scale.
We believe that Occupational Therapy is a client-based profession, one in which therapists must understand their patients' goals and meaningful activities to truly provide effective therapy. However, naturally we, as therapists, employ our own cultural framework to expedite this process. We function from assumptions about our patients that are inherent to our own culture, using presumed and simply understood cultural paradigms to approach therapeutic intervention. When crossing cultures and even sub-cultures this becomes an obstacle to effective therapy delivery. To provide effective therapy to individuals from diverse socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds, therapists must step outside of what occupational therapy scholars have called "culture blindness", being immersed in one's own culture so comprehensively that the therapist does not recognize their own cultural influences in the therapeutic relationship.
From my experiences in Guatemala and Nicaragua, I have come to realize that for culture blindness to subside and culturally competent occupational therapy to be delivered, therapists must take a step back from their traditional and assumed interventions and approaches and begin to look first at the theoretical foundations of occupational therapy. Therapists must first shave off the culturally biased flavors in which occupational therapy has developed and discover the raw underlying philosophy of the profession. From there we can allow this raw philosophical seed to grow in the natural culture of our patients, bearing the appropriate interventions and approaches rooted in the patients' own cultures and experiences.
This process requires a variety of factors to be in place. The first and foremost is rich soil into which the occupational perspective can be placed. Resources, time, and support are all necessary for the occupational perspective to be cultivated within a population in a way that connects theory to the patient in an authentic and effective manner. Unfortunately, just as Guatemalan campesinos have little land to cultivate their own crops, Guatemala and Nicaragua have little room to develop the occupational perspective. In Guatemala, the healthcare system is overburdened, disjointed, plagued with ethnic tension, overrun with NGOs, and has little room for prioritizing occupational therapy. In Nicaragua, what little occupational therapy is present is restricted by economic and political limitations, having neither the time nor the resources to effective emerge through the Nicaraguan culture.
Secondly, for the occupational perspective to take root and emerge through a new culture it must be interpreted effectively. Because of the huge presence of NGOs, service organizations, and foreign aid in Guatemala, much of the therapy is provided by non-Guatemalans who, although with good intentions, may not be providing the most effective or appropriate interventions for Guatemalan people. On many occasions, therapists provide interventions and techniques that come directly from their experiences in their respective countries instead of providing the reasoning and underlying philosophy behind those interventions to native therapists or caregivers. This creates a situation where patients, family members, or caregivers are performing interventions that may not make sense, are not effective, and maybe even create more of a burden rather than alleviating a problem.
As caregivers or therapists begin to realize that these transplanted interventions are not effective with their population, for example in Nicaragua, they resort to simplified non-occupation based techniques that do not resemble true occupational therapy. The occupational perspective, which was cultivated in Western/Developed cultures, has not been effectively interpreted for cultural differences outside that paradigm. Occupational therapy, because it is such a client based approach, must be acculturated before it can be sustainably effective. For this to occur, occupational therapists must step outside their own cultural paradigms and begin to understand the many structural and contextual factors that influence the efficacy of the therapy.
Understanding that in Nicaragua, the idea of independence may not be the most meaningful concept for a 75 year old woman because culturally she expects her children to care for her. Understanding that the routine of an indigenous woman in Guatemala may not have the flexibility to provide extra exercises to her child with special needs. Understanding that the standard approaches and solutions for assistive equipment, adaptive solutions, or even safety procedures may not be accessible, affordable, available, or of high quality. Understanding that therapists are viewed with less authority and less respect in some cultures. Understanding that sickness, disability, poverty, and independence are all viewed very differently within these cultural contexts.
For therapists crossing borders, it is integral to first understand these factors that affect their clients' in order to be creative, innovative, and revolutionary practitioners and effectively facilitate rehabilitation and/or change. Therapists crossing borders, whether that be across national borders or stepping into a homeless camp, work with tools that both hinder and facilitate potential success in their practice, having to take the time and effort to understand the full context of their patients while also bringing a new and diverse perspective on ways to resolve obstacles for their clients. It is the responsibility of therapists to find a balance between these two, uncovering a manner in which they foster occupational justice while preventing the imposition of their own culture.
![]() |
| Translation: "I want to be happy: To study and to play" |
Saturday, September 7, 2013
Nicaraguan Occupational Therapy: Seeing the Whole Picture
| Craft Materials |
display and understand the complexities of what is happening in Nicaragua with OT would take much more time to understand or even reflect on. Therefore I altered my approach and attempted to dive deeper into what I was seeing in the therapy room, what I was hearing from the therapists, and connect that to what I already knew about Nicaragua.
| Block Pusher |
Aldo has many departments including physical and occupational therapy, prostheses, aqua-therapy, and others I am sure I have not seen. I have focused all my time in the Occupational Therapy room working with a Nicaraguan occupational therapist and a physical therapist who has taken some courses in occupational therapy. I arrive at 7:30am every morning and begin observation from 7:30am to 10:00am. I have performed two different types of observations: 1) Patient observations - noting every exercise or action the patient performs during their time in therapy and 2) OT observation - noting every interaction, activity given, and other activities performed by the OT. These hours are the most populated by patients. After these hours I begin lending my time as a student by treating patients and actively observing treatment of other patients.
| Rheumatism Gym - Excercises for neck |
| Large Peg Board |
Some of the typical activities used are: large peg board (placing pegs in and out of holes), small pegs or blocks, standing while sliding objects across wires, wiping a slide board, removing and placing small velcroed squares or large tic tac toe pieces on a board, lifting rings from one pole to another, general shoulder exercises, wrist machines, squeezing hand strengtheners, screwing nuts on and off bolts, weaving shoe laces through small holes, finger ladder, and making circles and arcs on the table with an ace bandage. (See pictures of some of these activities throughout post). In the fact that I am able to even attempt to list most all the activities I have seen in one week, one can seen their repetitive and unvarying nature.
Sensory integration, autism, adapted technology, occupation based interventions, therapeutic use of self, mental health approaches, and environmental approaches, all of which are huge focuses today in OT, are rarely if at all present in the occupational therapy I am seeing in this Nicaraguan rehab hospital. Physical rehabilitation exercises and the bio-medical model prevail over any specifically occupation based theories or approaches. The PT told me that in the 80s, occupational therapy was provided to the psychiatric hospital near the rehabilitation hospital, but it no longer offers that to their patients. In my
| Ring Poles |
As I sat on my first few days, observing and noting all that I saw, I felt a pinch of condescension and authority believing that I already could see ways therapy at this hospital could be improved. As a student accustomed to the fast paced, function based, productivity oriented, and necessary one-to-one therapy of the United States, my first few days of observation left me frustrated, irritated, and asking
| Finger Ladder |
After a few days of internal self-touting, the OT actually asked me directly, "What are you seeing? What do you think about me?" with the attitude that she already knew what my answers would be, and she did. I provided my observations just as I did above. She then proceeded to explain to me her reasons why she had to provide therapy the way she did, recognizing very blatantly that she knew about occupation and occupational therapy and that she knew what she was doing wasn't the best therapy possible. As she continued, each of her reasons sharply poked holes in every view and recommendation I had. I slowly began to realize I had been roped into superficially looking at a situation, allowing myself to forget what this whole project has been about. By the end of the conversation, I realized instead of asking the question "Why won't they do more?" I should have been asking "Why can't they do more?". I needed to step back, understand the context, and see the whole picture.
In the next few paragraphs I will attempt to present my thoughts as to what the answer to this question might be, based in and informed by my observations, quite frank conversations with both therapists, and my current knowledge of Nicaragua and its structures.
When OT is Emphasized
| Exercises for the elbow and wrist |
| Materials in the Closet |
How OT is Viewed
As OT has grown its authority, prestige, scope of practice and scientific base as well as broadened its interventions through a deeper understanding of its philosophy and purpose, Nicaraguan occupational therapy has been left behind in a resource scarce context. As therapists become more respected in the developed world, the OT here notes that she feels least respected of all the therapists and that no one thinks OT is important. In the developed world, therapist have the ability to evaluate their patients and plan their treatments, here in Nicaragua the doctors decide the amount of time a patient will be in therapy, how often they will go, and sometimes even what specific activities they will be doing. She stated that patients often refuse to do what she asks and treat her poorly. Unfortunately, she also notes that her job is at risk if patients complain about things like her being too hard on them. For this reason she feels she cannot have more in depth and challenging relationships with the patients and therefore stands back and keeps her distance during therapy. With the patients who she can tell want to work and be challenged, she says she does build rapport and works with more closely. She does not enjoy the job security and support of an administration like many therapists do in the States when it comes to therapist respect, patient interaction, and complaints.
How OT Comes
| Tactile Materials |
| Craft Materials |
How OT has Adapted
It hasn't. Occupational therapy has not had the opportunity, resources, or personnel necessary in Nicaragua to flavor the profession to the needs of the Nicaraguan people. The occupational therapist has outdated and, due to the culture, ineffective techniques for providing therapy. She therefore resorts to non-function based repetitive exercises that lack the attributes that characterize occupational therapy. She understands the value of the diversion activities for mental health and the physical benefits of specific movements during those activities. However, I do not think the underlying philosophy of using meaningful occupations of the patient as a means and ends (which has more recently been more deeply developed in the profession) was emphasized greatly in her education due to context and time in which she received it. The other therapist who is by profession a physical therapist, commented that she had received one class from a professor from Philadelphia that did focus on this perspective. The professor supported the idea of using occupations relevant to Nicaraguan culture and the Nicaraguan people (e.g. planting a garden for the those patients who come from the countryside). The therapist said this could not continue after the professor left because the hospital did not have the resources to provide it. The lack of emphasis on this philosophy as well as the many other structural factors facing occupational therapists have hindered at least this Nicaraguan OT (one of the only ones giving occupational therapy) from applying it to her own culture and social systems, preventing her from developing applicable activities and occupations for her patients to perform. This leads to a stagnant and irrelevant existence for occupational therapy in Nicaragua as nothing more than physical exercise for the upper body.
Continued Conditions of OT
The word that I can use to best describe the OT I work with is burnt out. She is sometimes required to
| Small Pegs |
| Wrist Machines |
---------------------------
I began my week in the mind set of an occupational therapy student from the United States. As my week comes to an end, I find myself adapting and changing to the needs of the patients here, learning and understanding how to function within this setting. In my short time here, I won't be able to truly understand the complex situation that occupational therapy is existing within in Nicaragua, but I can at least gain a taste of the structural factors and circumstantial obstacles that face the occupational therapists working here. In the upcoming week, I hope to reflect more on how my own treatment, approaches, and presence changed as I begin working with more patients.
Saturday, August 31, 2013
A Special Familiy: A Nicaraguan Beginning
Many organizations in many countries work with individuals with special needs, however I have yet to come in contact with an organization that fulfills this goal from a community perspective more so than Familias Especiales [Special Families] in Matagalpa, Nicaragua. With practicality, comprehensiveness, and above all the community's needs informing its approach, the organization, over the past 2 decades, has learned that the driving force behind the services they provide has to be a dedicated commitment to listening.
| Accessible playground equipment at Familias Especiales |
| In the therapy room |
| Accessible playground equipment |
| All programs of Familias Especiales |
Familias Especiales demonstrates not only an understanding of this concept but also a dedication to improving structural factors affecting the families with which they work. For that reason, Familias Especiales takes the sunflower as its logo, a flower with many petals nourishing one plant. Familias Especiales has over 20 programs that seek to nourish one community from a variety of angles. Yes, this organization focuses on families of people with special needs but in working to support this portion of the population they have found ways to support the entire city of Matagalpa, including the special families.
For example the first big project the organization undertook was to build an accessible park in Matagalpa that both children with special needs and typical children could enjoy. This serves multiple purposes, however the two primary are firstly to provide a park for children with special needs and secondly to create a space for children and families of all types to come together, play, and interact as a community. This not only provides the occupation of play for many children, but it also uses occupation to facilitate a structural and social change in the community. Increased interaction with people with special needs will increase acceptance and integration in the community as a whole.
| Playground |
| Wheelchair Workshop |
| Recycling Operation |
| Piñata Making |
those with special needs. They support from all angles, attempting to recognize and work with all the factors affecting the special families. Their holistic and comprehensive practice of integrated community therapy has been an unprecedented model in my experience as an occupational therapy student. I hope to see more organizations like this one begin to emerge within the formal and domestic structures of all countries because the model and practice used by Familias Especiales is both inspiring and effective.
Monday, August 26, 2013
Thinking of Guatemala
| Guatemala was a long road, but it was a wonderful, colorful, and exciting adventure. |
| We learned about the good, the bad, and the ugly. |
| We tasted the rich resources Guatemala has in its beautiful hills... |
| ...and saw the beauty this country has to offer. |
| We were inspired by Guatemalan youth stepping out from the shadow of a civil war in the face of ... |
| ...poverty that still exists and oppression that continues to restrict human rights. |
| Its people are diverse. |
| They adapt... |
| They work hard. |
| They celebrate. |
And they live their lives, just like the rest of us... |
...asking only for their human rights... |
| ...in an uphill struggle... |
| ...against a visible and severe wealth disparity... |
| ...disease.... |
| ...and overwork... |
| ...but with a vision of hope Guatemala continues on... |
| ...day by day... |
| ...seeking peace, security, and love in a chaotic world... |
| ...and looking toward a better future. |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









